The OE pair narrowly defeated the School’s motion, This House would rejoin the European Single Market, at The 59th Annual Elizabethan Union Dinner Debate.
Anish Kumar and Shubh Rathod (both 2017-2024) argued that the point was not to relitigate the 2016 referendum, but to recognise that the world has moved on, with Europe left behind.
In an evening packed with tradition, sixth-formers Sejal Bobba and Shreyas Chandrasekar proposed the motion. The 2025 School Captain, Simardeep Sahota, toasted the visitors, while Shubh gave the toast to the Elizabethan Union – QE’s debating society.
Sejal began by noting that the Single Market is not the same as the European Union, since a participating country is not required to be in the customs union. Rejoining the single market would benefit the economy to the tune of £80-£90bn.
Anish, however, stated that having another referendum would reopen old problems, not least in Northern Ireland. The world is not moving towards Europe, but away from it, with other European countries and their economies struggling.
Shreyas urged looking to the future, not the past. Free movement would deal with labour shortages in the UK, and would help Europe, too. Since allies beyond Europe have become less reliable, we should stand with the European countries, he said.
Shubh, however, countered that leaving was difficult enough, so rejoining would be on unfavourable terms. He cited the significant amount the UK had to pay to rejoin the Erasmus scheme as an cautionary example. Our independence is helpful in giving the UK a measure of freedom in geopolitics and defence, and he noted the downsides of free movement in the context of refugee crises and instability.
A lively floor debate followed, during the course of which the proposers noted that net migration increased substantially after Brexit.
With an AI revolution looming, others pointed to the way in which Britain leveraged its independence during the Industrial Revolution to its huge advantage, warning that making an economic commitment to Europe would compromise its ability to work effectively with economic giants including the US, China and India.
The vote came down to a wafer-thin margin, with the motion defeated.
The pupils and OEs enjoyed a three-course dinner with a vegetarian option for the main course and sticky toffee pudding with salted caramel for dessert.
Blending present-day narration with memories, the documentary tells the story of how the gynaecological condition robbed sufferer Georgie Wileman of time.